The Ulu Team
Your options

Short sale vs. foreclosure vs. deed in lieu: an honest comparison

Daniel Ulu
Daniel Ulu
REALTOR® ASSOCIATE (S) 76778 · U.S. Coast Guard Veteran · Updated October 24, 2026 · 7 min read

The right conversation starts with your goal: keeping the home, or finding a workable way to leave it.

If you want to stay

Ask your servicer about available repayment, forbearance, and modification options. Eligibility and payment terms vary. A HUD-approved housing counselor can also help you review your choices.

A traditional sale

If the sale can cover the mortgage and transaction expenses, a traditional sale may be possible. Begin with a current market estimate and an itemized estimate of selling costs.

A short sale

If proceeds won’t cover the mortgage debt, the mortgage holders must agree to the proposed sale. Review the written approval, debt treatment, and expenses carefully. You will need a buyer and an agreed closing process.

A deed in lieu

A deed in lieu transfers the property to the servicer by agreement. It also requires approval and review of the debt terms. It is a different process from finding a buyer for a short sale.

Before choosing

Ask what happens to remaining debt, credit reporting, taxes, and any VA benefit. An attorney can review the legal terms, and a tax professional can address canceled debt. Don’t choose based solely on a claim that one option is always better for your credit.

Free & confidential
Not sure which door fits your situation? Let's figure it out together.
Get my free review →
Keep reading
The foreclosure timeline in Hawaiʻi: what happens after a missed payment → How a short sale affects your credit — and when you can buy again →

General information only — not legal, tax, financial, or credit advice. Whether a short sale, deed in lieu, or other alternative is available depends on your lender, loan, and circumstances, and requires lender — and where applicable, VA — approval. No outcome is guaranteed.